Alienation, Neoliberalism and Historic Preservation: Extractive Capital Captures US Heritage Law
Historic preservation in the United States has hardly been a revolutionary pursuit, but it sometimes is the closest practice to spatial democracy enumerated in federal law. The National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA; 1966) was born from an elitist, nostalgia-driven and art-historical coterie who embraced white supremacist political leaders and excluded indigenous people from shaping the law. The NHPA thus entered the juridical order more divorced from a more pluralistic version of cultural heritage law than its precedents (the 1906 Antiquities Act and the 1935 Historic Sites Act). Rather than join historic preservation’s regulation of the built environment with protections for archaeological and cultural traditions and regulation of the natural environment, the NHPA ensured that historic preservation would occupy a discrete corner of federal law where architecture (and sometimes other built resources) could find a reverent apparatus around which coalesced related enterprises of academic training, non-governmental advocacy and education and philanthropic funding.
Yet the NHPA managed to instantiate a function in which all of the federal and state officials, educated professionals and interested capitalists had to bend to the demands of ordinary people—at least in the law’s letter. That function makes a clumsy rallying cry, as it is simply stated as Section 106 of the NHPA. Under Section 106, heritage resources are extended protection from the destructive powers of the state that come in the forms of federal “undertakings”: funding and federal permitting for resource extraction. NHPA framers Carl Feiss and Laurence G. Henderson may have been consummate insiders in D.C., but their recommendation in the harbinger report With Heritage for All (1966) to extend heritage protection not simply to officially-inscribed sites but also to sites that may be eligible for inscription was a strongly egalitarian portal into the elite realm that the NHPA generated.
Under Section 106, any site – singly listed or listed in a district – inscribed in the National Register of Historic Places and/or listed as a National Historic Landmark has to be evaluated for what is defined as an “adverse effect” when there is a federal undertaking. Since the NHPA created the National Register, there was wisdom in extending evaluation beyond sites which would be inscribed in a register that did not yet exist. Hence the NHPA provides protection for sites that may be eligible for inscription – the same protection that inscribed sites hold. The NHPA empowers the enabled State Historic Preservation Offices (SHPOs) and Tribal Historic Preservation Offices (THPOs) with review of all undertakings as well as creating public engagement through consultations with interested organizations, tribes and other entities. All consultation is supposed to become open to the general public, so that it is not a negative review process but possibly a positive process of identifying what sites ordinary people may assert to be their heritage.
The NHPA in practice has been constrained by both the underfunding of entities which may have time to make Section 106 a capacious search for interest, the biases deepening in preservation agencies as professionalization normalizes exclusive training and the political influence of capitalist actors exerted on compliant governors and state officials. Still, it is significant that Section 106 affords a process in which consultation could empower ordinary people to level up with trained professionals, so that resources professionals would not consider significant may gain protection under federal law. Also significantly, under Section 106, anyone who feels like consultation is not opening consideration of popular values has the recourse of a civil lawsuit to compel a SHPO, THPO or federal agency to comply.

In the wake of a historic recapture of Congress by the Democratic Party, the lame-duck Congress is demonstrating why Americans should be cautious of assuming that the new Congress is ready to repudiate the market fundamentalism of decades of neoliberal “common sense” on Capitol Hill. Enter the insipidly-named Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA). Congress stands poised to pass a major “permit reform” bill that will break Section 106 of the NHPA in service to the extractive capitalism of Big Carbon and Big Mining – with a huge bipartisan bench of support. The gift to ordinary people who took to the polls to negate the tempestuous fascism of the Trump administration may well be a sucker-punch show of neoliberalism uniting the supposedly warring Republicans and Democrats.
Theorist Raymond Williams posited that there are three processes of ideology operating simultaneously in society: dominant, often understood as “common sense” or “the way things are” and shaping mass consciousness and power relations; emergent, or new concepts for social meaning, consciousness and power relations that are competing with the dominant but held by a minority; and residual, which are the “old says” shaped before the dominant ideology still circulating largely exhausted of anything but symbolic power. BAAJA demonstrates that in the US government, neoliberalism remains dominant ideology, and through pre-Reganite populist slogans like “affordability” and “jobs” utilizes residual ideological terms to dress its further dissolution of the commons.
Both defenders of the dominant ideology and champions of left-wing Democratic candidates may assert that the November election has unleashed a torrent of socialist force in the capital, but it is clear that the election merely expands the visibility and popularity of what remains an emergent ideology. BAAJA is the product of an economic order that has manipulated heritage laws for capitalist ends mostly benevolently—at least in terms of trading capital-accumulating tax credits for supporting bureaucratic funding for heritage agencies—until the Trumpian acceleration of late capitalist chaos. The surprise move is that the lilt toward dismantling historic preservation as a space in which ordinary people’s values can squash the primacy of capital formation is a space in which Trump and his supposed “resistance” Democrats comfortably are collaborating, including Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY), the steadfast foot soldier of neoliberalism’s manipulation of residual ideological tropes (labor, equality, public goods, “democracy”) to recuperate and neutralize potential opponents.
BAAJA does not simply revise the NHPA to make it more favorable to the extractive industries who are its primary beneficiaries. Instead the bill sacrifices the democratic potentials of Section 106 in the interest of the wealth accumulation of the smallest number of Americans possible, subverting the pretense that the NHPA serves any true public purpose. BAAJA simultaneously would codify a new plan to end the current revenue-neutral funding through Outer Shore oil natural gas leases of the Historic Preservation Fund (HPF)—a problematic, but provident product of Gerald Ford’s pre-neoliberal federalism—with an annual Congressional appropriation. The HPF provides crucial funding to SHPOs and THPOs, supporting staff as well as community-driven grants to solve local heritage problems. The HPF requires Congressional re-authorization, but the set of five- and ten-year renewals drew down to one-year hedges under President Barack Obama. Trump tried to eliminate the HPF in 2025, but it received a late one-year renewal. Now Trump critics are eagerly joining in a project to connect its reauthorization to how well preservation agencies accord with the wishes of the extractive capitalists.
Beyond that already salubrious move to allow capital to capture the very agencies that are supposed to regulate it in the service of vast majority of Americans, BAAJA also reduces the Section 106 consultation to a process in which only elite actors in the private and governmental sectors interact in a rigged closed loop. The bill removes any consideration of protections beyond built forms like buildings and designed landscapes, immediately removing protection for many indigenous heritage sites and also cultural landscapes connected to other groups. Adverse effect is defined down to impediments on “integrity” as already-too-narrowly defined by the National Register of Historic Places criteria. “Visual, atmospheric or audible element[s]” would be expressly disallowed as considerations in permitting undertakings.
Worse, the proposed law would hand all decisions under Section 106 to credentialled elites, showing that “Drain the Swamp” MAGA Republicans and “resistance” Democrats both join in manipulating false populist assertions of pre-neoliberal slogans around “the working class” and “decent Americans” to serve the interests of capitalism. The law would expressly forbid anyone who is not a formal party to an agreement created under Section 106 from being able to file a civil lawsuit to enforce the agreement. Under Section 106 currently, nonprofit groups and tribes are often parties. Yet the BAAJA limits eligible parties to officers in federal agencies, SHPOs and THPOs and federally-recognized tribal leaders. Federal agencies would have 60 days to report evaluations of undertakings to these inferior groups, and those groups would only have 90 days to respond. In the case of a substantive objection, the federal agency now would only have to issue a response or supplemental report noting that it considered the objection. End of story.

All of these proposals were also contained in the recommendation for a Section 106 overall recently advanced by the federal Advisory Council on Historic Preservation (ACHP), most of whose members are appointed by the president. The recommendations passed 15-3. Yet BBAJA shows that a process not controlled by Trump’s hand likely will yield the same results, as there is no dominant opposition to neoliberalism in the US Congress. The ACHP proposal looked obviously wagered by Trump’s White House to fulfill a breaking of the power of experts empower by bureaucracy. The BAAJA meanwhile comes across as an even more odious dismissal of the rights of ordinary people to direct the outcomes of decisions under historic preservation law. BAAJA is a complete capture of historic preservation by extractive capitalism under which remaining regulatory functions would be less than perfunctory and driven by an ideological agenda divorced from any real objective quest to identify American heritage of all kinds—architectural, landscape, archaeological, social and intangible.
Fundamentally, the BAAJA constitutes an instrument of neoliberal capitalism that enforces a legal alienation within historic preservation law—and alienation already felt by many professionals and activists who have engaged, disputed and agitated against the NHPA, itself a vehicle created to place the power of preservation in a small circle of hands. Whether remunerated or not, all people who engage Section 106 are engaged in acts of labor to interpret and direct the NHPA. The BAAJA would remove all power of any of the actors to engage in conceptual work, in which they would be empowered within legal proceedings to make claims, contest the wishes of market forces and interpret the NHPA. BAAJA directs bureaucrats to expedite permitting or face defunding and tells most people affected by permits that they have no role to tell their government what the NHPA can mean.
The new bill extends the brutal separation of conception and execution of labor that concerned Marxist labor theorist Harry Braverman. Braverman considered the power to conceive what work is needed and how to organize it to be essential to being a human being: “In human work… the directing mechanism is the power of conceptual thought, originating in an altogether powerful central nervous system.”[1] Yet he understood that industrialized capitalism required the removal of conceptual thinking from laborers so that they could execute in the manner proscribed by their bosses. In this separation of the faculties of conception and execution, the ability to actively conceive of labor “passes from the hands of the workers into [the boss’] own.”[2]

BAAJA would be the ultimate instrument of enforced alienation in historic preservation, an enterprise already framed on ways that disinvited many people from being involved in its conception. Under BAAJA, ordinary activists would be asked to sit down and shut up. Applicants could hire historic preservation consultants, but their jobs would be simply to get an approval. Workers at the federal, state and tribal offices would be even more constrained to narrow the scope of their evaluation and would face penalty for not delivering a market-favorable result. Not only does BAAJA attack the best democratic mechanism of US historic preservation law, it also zombifies the laborers who work within the shell that remains. If this is not the neoliberal triumph of whatever democratic parts of the NHPA ever existed, it would be impossible to recognize another one.
Of course, it could still be defeated in Congress. How?
[1] Harry Braverman, Labor and Monopoly Capital: The Degradation of Work in the Twentieth Century (Monthly Review Press, 1998), p. 32.
[2] Braverman, p. 39.